A Football Slamdunk

March 27th, 2014 at 9:45 pm

Not to mix metaphors, but as I read it, that National Labor Relations Board ruled that footballers at Northwestern are actually employees of the university and thus can form a union looks like a slamdunk.

You’ve got capital and labor.  The university owns the franchise, produces football, and captures hundreds of millions in profits.  But the owners play not on the gridiron.  They neither block nor tackle, pass nor punt.  The players do so, according to the NYT, sometimes for 50 hours a week.  That’s how they earn their scholarships.  That’s “earn”…as in work.

That’s labor, and importantly, labor that generates profit.  No one’s saying these players/workers/students/athletes don’t take classes.  But this argument by the school makes little sense to me:

Northwestern defended what is considered a sterling academic record: 97 percent of its football players graduate, the highest rate among universities in the top division of collegiate athletics.

The NLRB wasn’t buying it:

The ruling centered not on the treatment of players, but on the university’s relationship to them.

“Just because they’re a good employer doesn’t mean they’re not an employer,” said Tim Waters, the political director for the United Steelworkers, a union that has worked on rights for college athletes for more than a decade.

Wait a minute, you say.  So now every student with a scholarship “works” for the school and can collectively bargain?  Of course not.  Those non-athlete students are not generating revenues/profits for their schools on behalf of their “employers.”

And when I say revenue, I’m talking about the television contract for the new college football playoff system at $7.3 billion over 10 years, and the men’s NCAA basketball tournament at $10.8 billion over 14 years.

That’s the regional NLRB that made this call so now it goes up to the national board.  Like I said, you got your capital and you got your labor.  Now, maybe you got your union and some more of the fruits of their labor will find its way to the players.

Stay tuned.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

5 comments in reply to "A Football Slamdunk"

  1. save_the_rustbelt says:

    The athletes may have taken a giant step forward in making their scholarships and stipends taxable.


      • Patrick says:

        Scholarships probably not — the IRS already does not consider those taxable income. Stipends are already taxed since the 1986 tax reform. As a note to how this makes a difference, graduate teaching assistants are considered employees as well as students in some states (e.g. Michigan, Wisconsin, Illinois, New York, Oregon, Massachusetts, Minnesota, California etc) and not in others (Texas, Alabama, Maryland, Georgia etc) Their stipends are all taxed by the feds and their scholarships are all not.

  2. Wes Byrd says:

    Well, you could have titled this: A Football Home Run …

  3. tt says:

    i hope the athletes have taken the first step in shutting down the ncaa/big money sports in college